Two cactus in need of identification
Two cactus in need of identification
Can anyone identify these two cacti? I have no clue what they could be.
- Attachments
-
- IMG_20150527_071705.jpg (48.03 KiB) Viewed 1478 times
-
- IMG_20150527_074459.jpg (42.1 KiB) Viewed 1478 times
-
- IMG_20150527_075330.jpg (36.46 KiB) Viewed 1478 times
Budding cactus enthusiast
Twitter: jmoneypn
Instagram: jmoneypn
Twitter: jmoneypn
Instagram: jmoneypn
Re: Two cactus in need of identification
Left one is a monstrose Cereus (peruvianus or jamacaru).
I must admit I'm unsure (from the picture) if the other one is a cactus or a Euphorbia. Lower part seems to have single thorns (which might indicate a Euphorbia) but there seems to be multiple spines at the top (which would indicate a cactus). If you prick it with a needle and it bleeds white sap it is probably a Euphorbia.
I must admit I'm unsure (from the picture) if the other one is a cactus or a Euphorbia. Lower part seems to have single thorns (which might indicate a Euphorbia) but there seems to be multiple spines at the top (which would indicate a cactus). If you prick it with a needle and it bleeds white sap it is probably a Euphorbia.
Re: Two cactus in need of identification
What's the difference between a cactus and an Euphorbia?
Budding cactus enthusiast
Twitter: jmoneypn
Instagram: jmoneypn
Twitter: jmoneypn
Instagram: jmoneypn
Re: Two cactus in need of identification
Here's a better picture of the second cacti in question. It's a little sunburned right now but I am giving it shade using a small plastic pot for most of the day at the moment to give it time to recover.teo wrote:Left one is a monstrose Cereus (peruvianus or jamacaru).
I must admit I'm unsure (from the picture) if the other one is a cactus or a Euphorbia. Lower part seems to have single thorns (which might indicate a Euphorbia) but there seems to be multiple spines at the top (which would indicate a cactus). If you prick it with a needle and it bleeds white sap it is probably a Euphorbia.
Also a repeat of my reply. What is the difference between a cactus and Euphorbia?
Not sure why the pic came up sideways but there you are.
- Attachments
-
- 20150604_151612.jpg (71.72 KiB) Viewed 1466 times
Budding cactus enthusiast
Twitter: jmoneypn
Instagram: jmoneypn
Twitter: jmoneypn
Instagram: jmoneypn
Re: Two cactus in need of identification
They are totally different plant families - cacti are from America (north and south) - Euphorbias (at least the succulent ones) are mainly from Africa.
There is much to say about why they look alike but I won't go into that here![Smile :-)](./images/smilies/icon_smile.gif)
There is much to say about why they look alike but I won't go into that here
![Smile :-)](./images/smilies/icon_smile.gif)
Re: Two cactus in need of identification
That picture suggests a Hoodia (yet another plant family from Africa) but I think I will wait for someone more knowledgeable than me....
- greenknight
- Posts: 4825
- Joined: Tue Apr 30, 2013 4:18 am
- Location: SW Washington State zone 8b
Re: Two cactus in need of identification
What distinguishes cacti from other succulents is they have areoles (spine cushions), which your plant doesn't. I see the resemblance to a Hoodia, but I think they have single thorns only. Maybe Euphorbia virosa.
Spence ![Mr. Green :mrgreen:](./images/smilies/icon_mrgreen.gif)
![Mr. Green :mrgreen:](./images/smilies/icon_mrgreen.gif)
Re: Two cactus in need of identification
It is a Euphorbia. You could be sure by making a small cut or puncture in it and see if it bleeds white. Euphorbias virtually always have paired spines (if they have spines at all, some don't) just like your plant.
Euphorbias come from all over the world, though most succulent ones grow in Africa. Cacti are only from the Americas. Euphorbias bleed white, very few cacti do, and the ones that do don't bleed as heavily as a Euphorbia. Cacti can have paired spines but usually it is one or many. Euphorbias never have areoles where spines or hairs radiate out from a single point like a cactus. Cacti have showy flowers while Euphorbia's generally do not (I'm tempted to say virtually never but that would require a deeper botanical discussion than you may want).
The more cacti and Euphorbias you see the easier it will be to tell the difference when presented with a plant you've never seen before.
Euphorbias come from all over the world, though most succulent ones grow in Africa. Cacti are only from the Americas. Euphorbias bleed white, very few cacti do, and the ones that do don't bleed as heavily as a Euphorbia. Cacti can have paired spines but usually it is one or many. Euphorbias never have areoles where spines or hairs radiate out from a single point like a cactus. Cacti have showy flowers while Euphorbia's generally do not (I'm tempted to say virtually never but that would require a deeper botanical discussion than you may want).
The more cacti and Euphorbias you see the easier it will be to tell the difference when presented with a plant you've never seen before.
I'm now selling plants on Ebay. Check it out! Kyle's Plants
Re: Two cactus in need of identification
Do you happen to know what kind of Euphorbia it might be?Saxicola wrote:It is a Euphorbia. You could be sure by making a small cut or puncture in it and see if it bleeds white. Euphorbias virtually always have paired spines (if they have spines at all, some don't) just like your plant.
Euphorbias come from all over the world, though most succulent ones grow in Africa. Cacti are only from the Americas. Euphorbias bleed white, very few cacti do, and the ones that do don't bleed as heavily as a Euphorbia. Cacti can have paired spines but usually it is one or many. Euphorbias never have areoles where spines or hairs radiate out from a single point like a cactus. Cacti have showy flowers while Euphorbia's generally do not (I'm tempted to say virtually never but that would require a deeper botanical discussion than you may want).
The more cacti and Euphorbias you see the easier it will be to tell the difference when presented with a plant you've never seen before.
Someone else thought it might be virosa but I didn't think so because it doesn't have brown vertical lines along the column of spines. Could this be because it is a young plant our a different variety?
Budding cactus enthusiast
Twitter: jmoneypn
Instagram: jmoneypn
Twitter: jmoneypn
Instagram: jmoneypn
- greenknight
- Posts: 4825
- Joined: Tue Apr 30, 2013 4:18 am
- Location: SW Washington State zone 8b
Re: Two cactus in need of identification
It's young, and etiolated (had weak growth due to inadequate light, which is why it sunburned so easily). Once it makes some new, stronger growth you'll be able to identify it with more confidence. E. virosa was the best candidate I could come up with, but I'm far from certain.
Spence ![Mr. Green :mrgreen:](./images/smilies/icon_mrgreen.gif)
![Mr. Green :mrgreen:](./images/smilies/icon_mrgreen.gif)