Although I've dealt with these pests at various times since I built my current collection in 2011, '17 was a bad one when I got hit by all 3 in the same year. If (and more likely when) you encounter any of them, hopefully you'll be able to benefit from the experience I'm sharing with you here. This presentation is divided into 4 parts, and we'll put the first 3 under the heading of "know your enemy". The 4th part will discuss remedies.
Before we continue, I just wanted to thank CactiGuide for letting me use photos from the website's Cacti Pests & Diseases page. Thanks also to Harald (one of our "veteran" forum members) for his significant contributions to that page.
Part 1 -- scale insects
Mealybugs are a type of scale, and they're the most common cactus pest. I'm no stranger to mealies -- in fact, they were the bane of my young existence shortly after I started my first collection in 1970. What I didn't know then is that mealies can attack all parts of the plant, including the roots. I sure know it now, so first, we'll examine the ones we can obviously see. The above-ground kind attacking the stem...
and yes, even the spines:
Believe it or not, the primary culprit is the citrus mealybug Planococcus citri. If you'd like to get an in-depth look at this enemy, you'll find a good article on it at Wikipedia here.
Below-ground mealies are more insidious because they do their nasty work hidden from plain sight:
Root mealies were never a problem until I unpotted a Discocactus buenekeri to "prune" excess pups in early March 2017, so I was somewhat horrified to see a full-blown infestation. This prompted me to do some research, and the following quote from Cactus Nursery in the UK should be instructive:
"Root mealybugs (Rhizoecus falcifer) are among the worst pests of cacti and other succulents. They live almost exclusively on roots and the parts of the stem that are below the surface. They are similar to stem and spine mealybugs in that they also secrete whitish, woolly, or powdery wax. Root mealybugs prefer dry substrates. They multiply particularly rapidly during the dry winter dormancy period. Affected plants look pale, become sickly, and gradually die. Plants damaged and weakened by root mealybugs are especially susceptible to fungal diseases."
I was hoping the infestation would be localized only to the Discocactus, which I took care of in the appropriate manner. But when I repotted an Eriosyce senilis at the end of that May, there were -- root mealies. Uh oh. When I finally realized that they may have spread to other pots too, I noticed a number of cacti showing signs of illness which can be caused only by root mealy infestation. Here are a couple of examples from my collection. Exhibit A, Gymnocalycium baldianum on 5/22 and 6/13/17:
After regular springtime waterings, the Gymnocalycium should've been plumper. However, the roots weren't taking up enough water, and the skin color didn't look healthy at all.
Exhibit B -- Parodia subterranea on 3/25 and 6/18/17:
Once again, regular springtime waterings should've led to a plump and happily growing Parodia. Instead, the plant was going in the opposite direction, and its buds were aborting. 2 weeks after I repotted the Eriosyce, I was able to apply the remedy that got the entire collection on track for a mealy-free summer, so I'll show you a much nicer before-and-after view of these cacti in Part 4.
The other type of scale insect we'll commonly encounter is armored scale. Like mealies, A. they'll suck the juices out of our cacti, and B. infestations need to be knocked down before they go out of control and eventually kill the plant. From CactiGuide, this Astrophytum may be a goner:
Armored scale up close and personal:
Unlike mealies, this pest is selective about what it'll attack, although why armored scale goes after only some species is something of a mystery. Could it be that they can't latch onto thick-skinned cacti? Not necessarily -- Coryphantha retusa and Obregonia denegrii have thick waxy skins, but it wasn't enough to protect mine from being infested. I got the Coryphantha in July 2013, and my first run-in with these little nasties took place when they had fun at the plant's expense the following June:
Once I dealt with them, they never came back. When I received the Obregonia from an eBay seller in May 2016, it already had a low-level infestation:
After I knocked it down, the plant got infested again in 2017. Applying the (usually) effective treatment one more time should've done it, but the scale came back yet again the following year. While the Coryphantha bounced back from its one and only scale attack, it's possible that the seller sent me an Obregonia that wasn't healthy enough to prevent repeated assaults. I finally gave up and threw the thing away, so I'll simply chalk up the loss to bad luck. Anyway, since we know that armored scale can go after thick-skinned cacti, here's a follow-up question...
Maybe they won't find certain species tasty enough? Doesn't keep them from doing a "taste test", which I came to find out when they "tasted" my Astrophytum asterias, Melocactus matanzanus, and one of my Turbinicarpus polaskiis in 2018. While the insects didn't decide to go for an infestation, all it took was a few for the plants to be sickened just enough to be noticeable. The experience told me that if you see even a hint of armored scale on your plants, you should take remedial action right away.
A less comonly encountered type of scale insect is Cochineal:
As stated by CactiGuide's Pests & Diseases page, Cochineal insects confine themselves to Opuntia and Nopalea species, including Cylindropuntia. And the good news is that they won't kill the host plant.
Part 2 -- pest mites
Red spider mites are absolutely the worst because they're very aggressive in terms of infestation and reproduction. Although barely detectable with the unaided eye, the tiny webs they spin all over your plants are a telltale sign that you have them. A magnifier helps, so if you have one, here's what they look like:
Examples of the damage red spider mite infestations leave behind:
Red spider mites thrive in dry conditions, so if your climate tends to be humid, you won't see them. Shouldn't have a problem with mites then, huh? Unfortunately no, and this brings us to what is perhaps the least-understood cactus pest:
That's the flat mite Brevipalpus phoenicis, and you'll find an informative article on it at Wikipedia here. A quote from the article will tell you if flat mites could be a problem: "Ideal conditions for this species are a temperature range of 25–30 °C (77–86 °F) with high relative humidity." The Mediterranean coastal microclimate in my part of Los Angeles is humid enough for it, so thanks to Wikipedia, here's what I've learned about flat mites:
Adults grow to a length of 280 microns (0.011 in), which makes them impossible to detect without magnification. No telltale webs either, and I call them "drive by" pests because they'll come and go, leaving their damage behind before you know they were even there. From my collection, here's a Sulcorebutia rauschii with flat mites caught in the act (top) and an example of what their damage looks like (bottom):
2 more examples -- Gymnocactus ysabellae...
...and Eryosice odieri:
2017 was the year to see flat mites visiting my Coryphantha hesteri -- after the "drive bys":
Compared to red spider mites, flat mites aren't nearly as aggressive, and their reproductive cycles are slower. Another difference is that they tend to go after the base, although they can sometimes attack tender new growth as well. Hot days in winter (and I have more than a few of those) may encourage them enough to get active when cacti are dormant. For example, I took the Sulco rauschii photos I just showed you in early February 2014.
Chances are that you're hearing about flat mites for the first time here. Since you now know what their damage looks like (and your climate fits the profile), you'll be able to tell if you could have a flat mite problem. If you at least suspect that you do, a 10x magnifier will be helpful for confirmation. While catching them in the act can be tricky, regular plant inspections with a magnifier are highly recommended -- this applies to flat mites and red spider mites.
Part 3 -- vectors
A simple, yet fancy word for describing how we get pests to begin with. The most obvious vector is bringing uninvited "guests" home with you. The best cactus and succulent nurseries go to great lengths to maintain their reputations by selling only high quality pest-free plants. If that's what you're doing, then no worries, especially when you're getting bare-root cacti. If you're buying from private collectors of unknown reputation -- well, that could be problematic (it's how I ended up with a scale-infested Obregonia). General-purpose nurseries and "big box" garden centers certainly aren't the best because they know little or nothing about caring for the cacti they sell. Not to say that you should never buy plants from these places, but you'll need to inspect your cacti and/or succulents as closely as possible before you decide to make the purchase. Even then, there's no 100% guarantee that you're introducing pest-free plants to your collection, so your first order of business should be to immediately unpot and inspect them from top to bottom. If you see anything nasty, quarantine the affected plants so their tiny "hitchhikers" don't spread to the rest of your collection.
There's a vector that won't be obvious to inexperienced growers, and it has to do with the fact that 5 of the 6 pests we're discussing aren't specific to cacti. Neighborhood plant life may be the source of your ongoing pest problems, although the list of possible non-cactus hosts is way beyond the scope of this presentation. Bottom line is -- if you grow cacti, you'll be dealing with pests in one form or another. Regardless of how you got them, knowing your enemy is half the battle. This takes us to the other half...
Part 4 - remedies
Pest problems have short-term and long-term solutions, so I'll break it down by category.
- Short-term solutions
Pest mites -- Isopropyl alcohol (IPA) is the one miticide easily found worldwide because it's available at grocery stores and pharmacies. Used as a contact spray, IPA will kill mites instantly, although complete coverage is required so you don't have them hanging around on dry spots. There are a couple of drawbacks with IPA -- first, it can ruin the waxy skin of some cactus species, so be careful about that. And second, contact sprays kill adult mites, but it won't kill their eggs. As with scale insects, you'll be chasing after subsequent generations of mites. (It's what makes red spider mites such a pain, although flat mites are somewhat easier to deal with given their slower reproductive cycles.) So your plants don't develop a phototoxic reaction, spraying should be done away from direct sunlight, or better yet -- at night.
- Long-term solution for all types of scale insect
...followed by the Parodia on 6/18 and 9/23:
That Imidacloprid really did wonders, didn't it?
Soil soaks have to be done when cacti are active in the growing season, and spring is the best time if you'd like to do this as a preventative measure. Some people tend to take a more cautious approach, reaching for the Imidacloprid only if they detect signs of a scale problem. I used to be one of those people before I saw what happened in 2017 and '18. Long story short, I discovered that ants from a nearby Bougainvillea bush were responsible for the stem and root mealies infesting some of my cacti in 2017. Then when the armored scale came back the following year, I said "enough is enough" -- implemented in spring 2019, the entire collection has been getting a preventative soil soak every year. This makes sense because I know that the mealies and armored scale are coming from sources beyond my control. If you find yourself in a similar situation, annual prevention is a good idea. If you don't have a problem with scale insects that keep coming back every year, you can take the more cautious approach with soil soaks only on an as-needed basis.
- Important note: Contrary to what you may have heard or read elsewhere, Imidacloprid protection with soil soaks has an expiration date of about 3 months. If you do a soil soak in April or May and you see mealies/armored scale showing up in July or August, give the affected plant(s) another soil soak.
https://www.amazon.com/Bonide-037321006 ... 220&sr=8-7
The Bonide product contains 1.47% Imidacloprid, dilute 1/4 cup per gallon of water or 1 tbsp. per quart for growers who have only a few plants they need to soak. Just be aware of the fact that the concentrate doesn't dissolve quickly, so here's a "how to":
- When you pour the concentrate into your container of water, make sure you have the its cap on tight (but not too tight!), and shake like the dickens. After a couple of minutes, take off the cap and see if the Bonide is thoroughly dissolved. If it's not, put the cap back on, and shake like the dickens again, then take off the cap to see if it's thoroughly dissolved. If it's still not fully diluted, either go through the process again or let the container sit for an hour, and give it a final shake-shake-shake. The point is to make sure that you don't have clots of Bonide concentrate floating around in the water when you apply your soak.
6/11/2022 update
I've been using Imidacloprid for 11 years, and I realized that I very well could end up with Imidacloprid-resistant pests. The problem was trying to find something we can rotate it with, and a systemic product that isn't a neonicotinoid. Thanks to a recent recommendation Craig Fry posted in this thread, we found a good one -- Cyzmic CS, available on Amazon:
https://www.amazon.com/CSI-Cyzmic-Contr ... 192&sr=8-2
Dilution is 12 ml (2.5 tsp.) per gallon of water. Luckily, I'm not seeing any telltale signs of mealies or armored scale, but if I do, it'll be Cyzmic.
- Long-term solution for pest mites
My miticide of choice is TetraSan, and it's in granular form -- dilute 1/2 teaspoon in a gallon of water. I recently discovered another translaminar miticide I can use to rotate with TetraSan, and the active ingredient is Abamectin sold under the Avid brand name. It comes in liquid form -- dilute 1/4 tsp. in a gallon of water. Avid and TetraSan have an upside and a downside. The downside is that both products are really expensive. But a little bit goes a long way, so for those of us with relatively small collections, the upside is that we can do one-stop shopping with Avid and TetraSan being sold in small quantities through The Flytrap Store. (Oddly enough, carnivorous plant growers have the same mite problems we have!) To get the best translaminar effect, spray your cacti at night when their stomata are open so that the miticide penetrates the skin's outer layer. Important note regarding Avid: Unlike TetraSan (which is a "spray once" application), you'll need to apply Avid by spraying on day 1, spraying 3 days later, then spraying again 3 days after that.
I have zero experience with red spider mites, so I don't know if preventative measures are warranted. Since you can actually see them (or at least their telltale webs), that would be the time to go for the TetraSan or Avid spray. If they come back, you'll be prepared for them as you rotate miticides. My personal experience is confined to dealing with flat mites, so the problem I have to consider stems from the fact that I won't know if they're there or not. Such being the case, I decided to make 2018 the year for beginning a regular preventative treatment schedule, rotating between TetraSan and Avid every month or so in the spring and summer. They seem to give up the fight rather easily, so I'm not too concerned about the possibility of seeing resistant flat mites over the long haul.
Thoughts, anyone?
This thread is wide open for discussion, so please feel free to post comments, suggestions, tips, etc. And there are a few things that would be especially helpful...
- Products we can add to the anti-pest toolkit
A. Specify the product's brand name and what it does.
B. Tell us if the product is currently available to hobbyists. Environmental regulations vary from state to state, but unless the product is sold only to professionals, hobbyist growers can determine whether or not they'll be able to buy it in their state.
C. Let us know about where we can find the product online if it's not something obvious (like Amazon or eBay).
- If you live outside the US
Okay, folks -- let's go after those pests!