What is this smelly succulent?

If you have a succulent plant and need help identifying it, this is the place to post it.
User avatar
PlantCrazy
Posts: 34
Joined: Tue Jul 26, 2022 7:45 pm
Location: Scotland, UK

What is this smelly succulent?

Post by PlantCrazy »

Hello Everybody,

I would love to know the proper names for this plant. I think it's beautiful. It has white hairs along the edges of it's leaves, and at certain times of the day it smells like really stinky socks!
It was a large, multi-branched plant that I dissected for cuttings, and the single headed plant is one of the pups and shows a vibrant burgundy colour.

My guesses are some sort of Aeonium or an Echeveria?

I'm still learning!
Attachments
rsz_120220905_191400.jpg
rsz_120220905_191400.jpg (85.49 KiB) Viewed 2877 times
rsz_120220905_191430.jpg
rsz_120220905_191430.jpg (77.25 KiB) Viewed 2877 times
User avatar
Tom in Tucson
Posts: 426
Joined: Sun Jan 02, 2022 4:12 pm
Location: NW Tucson AZ area

Re: What is this smelly succulent?

Post by Tom in Tucson »

It looks like an Aeonium cultivar.
User avatar
PlantCrazy
Posts: 34
Joined: Tue Jul 26, 2022 7:45 pm
Location: Scotland, UK

Re: What is this smelly succulent?

Post by PlantCrazy »

Tom in Tucson wrote: Thu Sep 08, 2022 8:33 pm It looks like an Aeonium cultivar.
Thanks, Tom. That's a start.
User avatar
nachtkrabb
Posts: 1540
Joined: Tue May 23, 2006 7:07 pm
Location: Stuttgart, Germany

Re: What is this smelly succulent?

Post by nachtkrabb »

Hello,
did you find out by now? I would think about Aeonium, too, by the form of the leaves.
But that information about the smell is really interesting, I never heard of that -- of any plant. Does ist still do that?
N.
Love and Revolution!
...and still more cacti.
User avatar
Tom in Tucson
Posts: 426
Joined: Sun Jan 02, 2022 4:12 pm
Location: NW Tucson AZ area

Re: What is this smelly succulent?

Post by Tom in Tucson »

nachtkrabb wrote: Fri Aug 04, 2023 9:13 pm Hello,
did you find out by now? I would think about Aeonium, too, by the form of the leaves.
But that information about the smell is really interesting, I never heard of that -- of any plant. Does ist still do that?
N.
The best known species is Aeonium balsamiferum.

Many species have glandular like leaves which are hairy (also sticky), and supposedly use excretions to lower transpiration (weird).
User avatar
nachtkrabb
Posts: 1540
Joined: Tue May 23, 2006 7:07 pm
Location: Stuttgart, Germany

Re: What is this smelly succulent?

Post by nachtkrabb »

Tom in Tucson wrote: Sat Aug 05, 2023 9:07 pm The best known species is Aeonium balsamiferum.

Many species have glandular like leaves which are hairy (also sticky), and supposedly use excretions to lower transpiration (weird).
WOW! Of course I know "smells" from herbs, spices, vegetables, flowers etc. But that succulents use excretions to control their loss of water -- really weird. #-o Never heard about that.
A.balsamiferum has a very adequate name then. :D Great. But the source of that name seems to be quite unknown, just as the plant: Llifle doesn't list it. Wikipedia in EN & DE usually give the source of the epitheton, but not here. Is that too weird, so that they do not dare to say so...? :shock:

How in all the world did you stumble on that information, Tom? Do you breed that Aeonium, or similar plants? Would you like to tell?

BTW: These days the smell on my balcony might have changed. Sometimes I look out for opened flowers which I do not find, but it is always just a whiff. Also there are a lot more flies than usual. I will sniff & snoop around like a bloodhound to find out if its one of my (new?) plants. Until now I hadn't thought of that possiility.
Thanks,
Nachtkrabb aka Snoopy
Love and Revolution!
...and still more cacti.
User avatar
nachtkrabb
Posts: 1540
Joined: Tue May 23, 2006 7:07 pm
Location: Stuttgart, Germany

Re: What is this smelly succulent?

Post by nachtkrabb »

PlantCrazy wrote: Thu Sep 08, 2022 8:43 pm
Tom in Tucson wrote: Thu Sep 08, 2022 8:33 pm It looks like an Aeonium cultivar.
Thanks, Tom. That's a start.
Hello PlantCrazy,
did you check the said A. balsamiferum, A. arboreum & its cultivars & A. mascaense....? Or have you already found out the name?

Did I already write that I do like your photographs? They are very expressive and like a fairy tale at the same time. Sorry, I am no native speaker, I don't no how to express myself but with "very well done". :oops:
N.
Love and Revolution!
...and still more cacti.
User avatar
Tom in Tucson
Posts: 426
Joined: Sun Jan 02, 2022 4:12 pm
Location: NW Tucson AZ area

Re: What is this smelly succulent?

Post by Tom in Tucson »

nachtkrabb wrote: Sat Aug 05, 2023 11:02 pm
Tom in Tucson wrote: Sat Aug 05, 2023 9:07 pm The best known species is Aeonium balsamiferum.

Many species have glandular like leaves which are hairy (also sticky), and supposedly use excretions to lower transpiration (weird).
WOW! Of course I know "smells" from herbs, spices, vegetables, flowers etc. But that succulents use excretions to control their loss of water -- really weird. #-o Never heard about that.
A.balsamiferum has a very adequate name then. :D Great. But the source of that name seems to be quite unknown, just as the plant: Llifle doesn't list it. Wikipedia in EN & DE usually give the source of the epitheton, but not here. Is that too weird, so that they do not dare to say so...? :shock:

How in all the world did you stumble on that information, Tom? Do you breed that Aeonium, or similar plants? Would you like to tell?

BTW: These days the smell on my balcony might have changed. Sometimes I look out for opened flowers which I do not find, but it is always just a whiff. Also there are a lot more flies than usual. I will sniff & snoop around like a bloodhound to find out if its one of my (new?) plants. Until now I hadn't thought of that possiility.
Thanks,
Nachtkrabb aka Snoopy
First off, just so you don't expect any reply soon, PlantCrazy hasn't logged in since Jan 09, 2023.

I don't think the species is controversial. See IPNI ref.:

Aeonium balsamiferum Webb & Berthel., Hist. Nat. Iles Canaries (Phytogr.). 3(2:1): 192 (1840) (1840).

Publication
Histoire Naturelle des Iles Canaries, ...Tome troisieme [Botanique] pt. 2. Phytographia
Canariensis. Paris

Collation
3(2:1): 192 (1840)

Family as entered in IPNI
Crassulaceae

Type Information
Distribution Of Types
Canary Is.

Remarks
Phyt. Canar. i. 192

BTW, sticky leaved succulents aren't confined to Aeonium. Sheck out Dudleya viscida.
User avatar
nachtkrabb
Posts: 1540
Joined: Tue May 23, 2006 7:07 pm
Location: Stuttgart, Germany

Re: What is this smelly succulent?

Post by nachtkrabb »

Hello Tom,
thank you for the information, so I won't expect ANY answer by PlantCrazy.
Sorry, I never questioned the name of Aeonium balsamiferum. I was just astonished, that 1. it wasn't listet at Llifle & 2. that I read nowhere about the smell as cause of the name.
Does that Dudleya also have an interesting scent? Do you know?
N.
Love and Revolution!
...and still more cacti.
User avatar
Tom in Tucson
Posts: 426
Joined: Sun Jan 02, 2022 4:12 pm
Location: NW Tucson AZ area

Re: What is this smelly succulent?

Post by Tom in Tucson »

nachtkrabb wrote: Sun Aug 06, 2023 4:44 pm Hello Tom,
thank you for the information, so I won't expect ANY answer by PlantCrazy.
Sorry, I never questioned the name of Aeonium balsamiferum. I was just astonished, that 1. it wasn't listet at Llifle & 2. that I read nowhere about the smell as cause of the name.
Does that Dudleya also have an interesting scent? Do you know?
N.
I used to grow it in San Diego, and although I can vouch for it's stickiness, I have no memory of any flagrance. I got rid of a large part of my collection before moving to Tucson (for various reasons), and it was one of many to go.
User avatar
nachtkrabb
Posts: 1540
Joined: Tue May 23, 2006 7:07 pm
Location: Stuttgart, Germany

Re: What is this smelly succulent?

Post by nachtkrabb »

Tom in Tucson wrote: Sun Aug 06, 2023 7:37 pm I used to grow it in San Diego, and although I can vouch for it's stickiness, I have no memory of any flagrance. I got rid of a large part of my collection before moving to Tucson (for various reasons), and it was one of many to go.
...what a pity...
Thank you, Tom.
Love and Revolution!
...and still more cacti.
Mrs.Green
Posts: 1083
Joined: Fri Oct 23, 2020 5:59 pm

Re: What is this smelly succulent?

Post by Mrs.Green »

Regarding ‘smelly’ cacti; One of my christmas cacti have a faint pleasant odour ( out of blooming). The odour is as said very faint and I have problems placing it, it’s like a very faint perfume of some sort. I can clearly smell it when bending over the plant. What’s causing it, I don’t know.
User avatar
Aeonium2003
Posts: 303
Joined: Sun Sep 26, 2021 2:53 am
Location: Central California

Re: What is this smelly succulent?

Post by Aeonium2003 »

Tom in Tucson wrote: Sun Aug 06, 2023 7:37 pm I don't think the species is controversial

Yes, A. balsamiferum is an accepted species. As far as I know it has no synonyms (other than when Aeoniums were classified as Sempervivum).

See: https://www.crassulaceae.ch/de/artikel? ... B&aID=3025

About scented Aeoniums,
A. balsamiferum has pubescent leaves, and a distinct aroma.
A. canariense and goochiae and some of their hybrids also have distinct smells.
A. xsantosianum (a hybrid of goochiae and canariense v. palmense) has a distinct coniferous smell.
some A. canariense hybrids like A. 'Blushing Beauty' and A. 'Velour' (which are hybrids of A. canariense and A. arboreum 'Zwartkop') have similar smells to A. balsamiferum.

As for sticky Aeoniums, glandulosum and glutinosum are some of the stickiest. I've noticed flies getting stuck to A. glutinosum :shock:.

P.S. interesting to hear about D. viscida, Tom. I hope to grow that species some day. :D
User avatar
Tom in Tucson
Posts: 426
Joined: Sun Jan 02, 2022 4:12 pm
Location: NW Tucson AZ area

Re: What is this smelly succulent?

Post by Tom in Tucson »

Aeonium2003 wrote: Wed Aug 09, 2023 4:38 pm
Tom in Tucson wrote: Sun Aug 06, 2023 7:37 pm I don't think the species is controversial

Yes, A. balsamiferum is an accepted species. As far as I know it has no synonyms (other than when Aeoniums were classified as Sempervivum).

See: https://www.crassulaceae.ch/de/artikel? ... B&aID=3025

About scented Aeoniums,
A. balsamiferum has pubescent leaves, and a distinct aroma.
A. canariense and goochiae and some of their hybrids also have distinct smells.
A. xsantosianum (a hybrid of goochiae and canariense v. palmense) has a distinct coniferous smell.
some A. canariense hybrids like A. 'Blushing Beauty' and A. 'Velour' (which are hybrids of A. canariense and A. arboreum 'Zwartkop') have similar smells to A. balsamiverum.

As for sticky Aeoniums, glandulosum and glutinosum are some of the stickiest. I've noticed flies getting stuck to A. glutinosum :shock:.

P.S. interesting to hear about D. viscida, Tom. I hope to grow that species some day. :D
Well compiled set of species with similar attributes.

As to Dudleya viscida, it's not a terribly exciting member of the genus. One thing that could be considered annoying about it is it's tendency to collect a lot of wind-born debris on the leaves acting a lot like fly paper.
User avatar
nachtkrabb
Posts: 1540
Joined: Tue May 23, 2006 7:07 pm
Location: Stuttgart, Germany

Re: What is this smelly succulent?

Post by nachtkrabb »

Aeonium2003 wrote: Wed Aug 09, 2023 4:38 pm (...) I've noticed flies getting stuck to A. glutinosum :shock:. (...)
Tom in Tucson wrote: Wed Aug 09, 2023 7:24 pm (...) As to Dudleya viscida, it's not a terribly exciting member of the genus. One thing that could be considered annoying about it is it's tendency to collect a lot of wind-born debris on the leaves acting a lot like fly paper.
...Plants collecting flies...? Leaves acting like fly paper...? #-o Those aren't carnivorous plants, are they...?! :-k
Is that just a side effect or.....?
N.
Love and Revolution!
...and still more cacti.
Post Reply